Sunday, November 20, 2011

Black Friday: a blessing




Black Friday: a blessing


This article is dealing with the shopping holiday after Thanksgiving Day. Black Friday, rebranded in the 1960s to reference the accounting practices of writing gains in black ink and losses in red instead of the US market crash in 1864, has become its own holiday in recent years (Time). It has become “the most important shopping day in the year” in the world of retail (NY Times). Sure there are Thanksgiving sales, but they don’t start until the next day so that the Thanksgiving can be enjoyed to its fullest. Right?
This year it’s a different story. This Friday marks Target and many retailers’ earliest opening ever following Thanksgiving. Target, Best Buy, Macy’s, and Kohl’s are all opening at 12:00am on Friday morning. Wal-mart pushed the time to 10 pm on Thanksgiving, and Toys-R-Us upped the ante by opening at 9 pm the same day.
This new early opening policy has many customers, and employees upset that these retailers would “rob…workers of time off with their families on Thanksgiving Day” (Change.org). This opinion is 189,000 people strong according to the petition set up by Anthony Hardwick on advocacy site Change.org. Though I sympathize with Mr. Hardwick’s situation, and his feelings may represent a large populous, however I believe that there are many people who are happy with the new opening policy, and its not just the customers.
As an employee of one of these retailers I am indeed scheduled to be present on Black Friday. Yes I have a very early, long, and what I am sure will be, busy shift. Yet I am quite happy with the situation, as I feel are many employees of major retailers nationwide. I’m not talking about the CEOs of these companies, though I am sure they will be pleased with the revenue that is certain to be generated from the day. I am referring to the full and part timers that are working at these locations to get though school or put food on the table. The portion of the population that is struggling with paying bills and other expenses should see the new opening time as an opportunity.
Most retail stores make huge exceptions for hours able to work during the holidays. Black Friday is one of these events that many companies are perfectly fine with allowing full timers to go deep into over time and letting both full and part timers receive holiday pay. Those employees fortunate enough to work after midnight on Thanksgiving eve will qualify for holiday pay for most retail establishments which in some cases means time and a half for many of these companies. In addition, many full timers will be pushed into over time for that week, which again typically earns time and a half pay. What an opportunity! For a few hours Wednesday night a retail employee can earn time and a half while preparing the store for the opening on Thanksgiving night. On top of that, a full time employee can earn time and a half again for what is likely a 12-hour shift. This means that a full time employee could make almost half a week’s worth of pay in one day in addition to those hours on Wednesday night. That would definitely help make the holidays a little brighter, by either allowing more gifts to be purchased or keep the lights and heat on for a longer period of time.
I do not feel as though I am giving up my Thanksgiving holiday to meet these demands made by my employer. I have pulled all nighters before and could do it again if I had to despite that my schedule for that day is 4am – 4pm. I will still have my Thanksgiving dinner, sleep for a little while, have a coffee and go to work. I could also use the extra money to prepare for the remaining gifts I have to purchase. Yet I think that there is a large group of people who will not even be celebrating Thanksgiving. While traditionally Thanksgiving is a day to gather and celebrate the opportunities you as an individual have been afforded in your lifetime, many people do not consider this a special day. Thanksgiving is very much an American holiday, one steeped in American history, even if there is a definite event to base it on or not. For this reason, there must be a large immigrant population that is more than happy to work the overnight shift on Friday, because for them it will be just another day at work.
The thing that I find to be the most ridiculous part of this entire situation is the protests it has incited. A friend of mine invited me to a Protest Black Friday event on my facebook account, despite the fact that I list my employer on my profile. An extension of the Occupy movement the protest urges shoppers not to shop on that day at all, or only at small businesses. The main goal of the protest was to curtail the “mindless consumerism” that the day encourages (Facebook). The protest page’s other goal was to make the large corporations “go into the red” (Facebook). In other words, shoppers should avoid shopping at these retailers so much so that the biggest sales day of the year, the day at which most retail becomes profitable, or goes into the black, continue to loose money. Thereby “sticking it to the man” and hurting the 1% as defined by the Occupy movement. I think that the protest ignores one thing though (Facebook). If these retailers do not become profitable on this day, millions of people will have their jobs in question. These corporations rely on this day to make up for the entire year. Without this day company stocks will fall and unemployment will increase. The protest does not consider that many employees have invested lots of money back into the company by buying stocks. The protest doesn’t consider that employees will suffer more from the protest than the companies.
Whether you shop this Friday or not, all these retailers will still be open at their announced times, the lines will be there and so will I. I will be punching in at 3:55 am and will be lucky to walk out of the store at 4:00 pm. Like many employees, there will however still be a smile on my face, because this Thanksgiving, I am thankful for a steady job and a decent wage.


References
Dickler, J. (2011, November 18). Black Friday backlash: Early openings a mixed blessing - Nov. 15, 2011. CNNMoney - Business, financial and personal finance news. Retrieved November 20, 2011, from http://money.cnn.com/2011/11/15/pf/black_friday_backlash/index.htm?iid=HP_Highlight
Economic Justice Petition: Tell Target to Save Thanksgiving | Change.org. (n.d.). Change.org - Start, Join, and Win Campaigns for Change. Retrieved November 21, 2011, from http://www.change.org/petitions/tell-target-to-save-thanksgiving
Fletcher, D. (2009, November 27). A Brief History of Black Friday - TIME. Breaking News, Analysis, Politics, Blogs, News Photos, Video, Tech Reviews - TIME.com. Retrieved November 20, 2011, from http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1942935,00.html
GOODMAN, P. S. (n.d.). Black Friday (Shopping) News - The New York Times. Times Topics - The New York Times. Retrieved November 20, 2011, from http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/subjects/r/retail_stores_and_trade/black_friday/index.html

Stephens, R. (n.d.). Retrieved November 20, 2011, from http://www.facebook.com/events/178999168854380/

11 comments:

  1. Great job Grant, really well written and I agree completely with you on this. It hurts the every day employee a lot more than it hurts the CEO. If the company goes bankrupt the CEO still has millions of dollars in his bank account to live off of but the every day worker can no longer put food on the table or pay their way through school. How is this helping the so called 99%?

    Hope you have a good holiday buddy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really love your perspective when discussing the “occupy” people in that if they are successful in putting a damper on sales, (which is extremely unlikely) it could have some serious repercussions. I have never been a Black Friday shopper, in fact I thought that those people were always crazy, but with the deals that these companies are offering, you’d almost be crazy to not take advantage of it. That’s something these protestors aren’t thinking about, and it’s blatantly obvious. If I can buy something for 50% off that I was going to buy anyway, I can use that 50% to purchase something else, or save for my family. So although Black Friday has a very positive effect on the companies, It has a serious positive effect on the shoppers involved. I cannot wait till these protestors realize that they aren’t proving any points, except the fact that the number of stupid people in this country truly is growing daily.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have to say I think this was a very well done news item response and I do agree with it. I used to never go to any of the Black Friday sales and I also used to think that the people who did were out of their minds to go through everything they did for a sale. However now that I am not living at home and am a broke college student for me Black Friday really is the most important shopping day of the year. Being able to get nice gifts for my family at often 50% off even with fighting the crowds I feel that Black Friday is important for those on hard times. I do not agree with the protesters and while I do think it would hard to work on Black Friday but I think most of the people who do it are just happy to have a job just as you said you are.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I enjoyed reading this article from a perspective I was not anticipating when I read the title of the blog. I, like most college students, am working part-time to help pay for college. Now I am a traditionalist, and I absolutely have to have my Thanksgiving, food, football, and family. As a traditionalist, the men in my family usually stay home and watch even more football and the women in my family go and wait in all the crazy lines and grab all the insane deals on the hottest items. So personally, I have never experienced Black Friday, but I have experienced working at a place where there is an abnormal rush of business when I would rather be doing something else. This happiness to help pay bills and tuition is completely relatable and I may even consider getting off my rump and checking out some of these deals myself this year thanks to your article. If I do, I will make sure that I am a low maintenance customer, and will tell each and every single employee that helps me Happy Thanksgiving because they could be with their families.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I very much agree with most of what you have said. There are many who are in need and are thankful for the extra work. Black Friday is one of those days which will continue to bring in the crowds. I have heard a few mentions of this early start for the retailers, but did not realize how many people were participating in the change. While I agree that protesting this holiday would be an unsettling idea for most, I will be in the same place that I am every year during this particular holiday… deep in my annual tryptophan induced coma.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You would think by 9 or 10 pm people would be done with family events. I have to drive back up to columbus on Thanksgiving because I work early Saturday morning. In this job market I am just happy to ba able to work.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think you make some very good points about Black Friday that many people wouldn't have thought about. I have worked in an electronics retailer on Black Friday and although it can be a hectic and stressful time, it was probably one of the biggest paydays I ever had. Your right that for people struggling right now and needing as many hours on their pay check as possible, working these long shifts on the holidays making overtime is extremely beneficial for everyone. It's shocking to see how early these stores are opening now and sooner or later their just never going to close on thanksgiving and start sales earlier and earlier as more people demand to get those once in a lifetime deals on that one day.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I really enjoyed your article. I have been getting countless emails and Facebook invites about the new Black Friday work schedules as well. I wouldn’t say that I don’t see their point in arguing for change, but I do believe that these protestors are looking at the glass as half-full. I myself had to work at midnight on Thanksgiving last year, so I know what it’s like. Yes, it isn’t the ideal way to wrap up one’s holiday, but it is an opportunity to make more money, and lets face it, money is what keeps society going, whether people want to admit it or not. Good post, and I never knew what Black Friday actually meant before, so thanks for the definition!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Very good post, even though I support most of what the Occupy movement is doing I don't feel like this is going to have a major impact on sales at all. I myself have to work black friday this year and I still feel it would just be as busy if not more than last year. I feel like that they can put their time and energy somewhere else not the consumer.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for posting this article! I am working at a restaurant this Black Friday, and it will be crazy but I will be more than happy to make a little bit of mad money for the holiday season. I can absolutely see where the Occupy protesters are coming from, but I am one those everyday people who will be benefiting from the massive amount of people out and about going for the deals. Besides, I think that it makes for an exciting start to the holiday season!

    ReplyDelete
  11. If anyone would like to continue this discussion, I thought I would inform the commenters of this blog, as well as future readers, that at my workplace, a man set up his tent outside the store at 6:00pm today. Let me know what you think.

    ReplyDelete